World Famous Comics: The Case of Madeleine Smith: The Case of Madeleine Smith (Treasury of Victorian Murder (Graphic Novels))
The Case of Madeleine Smith: The Case of Madeleine Smith (Treasury of Victorian Murder (Graphic Novels))
By: Rick Geary Publisher: ComicsLit Average Rating: Binding: Hardcover Label: ComicsLit Number of Items: 1 Number of Pages: 80 Publication Date: 2006-07
Average Entry Geary has built up so much good will in this series that I will continue to buy them... but this is just an average entry. In 1857 a Glasgow man dies, his secret girlfriend is a suspect. At her trial she gets off. This story really lacks developments or nuances, but it's still kind of long. I pulled the Jack the Ripper edition out to refresh my memory about why I love these books and was struck by visuals that were stronger, more dynamic and more imaginative. This book conforms to the more procedural aspects of Geary's The Beast of Chicago, relaying even run-of-the-mill (non-interesting) aspects of the case. For all the detail in this book (It might be the thickest volume) I really craved more complications. There just aren't any major moments in it, or anything that makes your blood curdle. Here again, as in the Borden Tragedy and Mary Rogers, Geary tracks the protagnist into old age, but those two stories had a coda. This has none. There's no final incident that makes Madeleine's story pursuable. It seems to be here because it's become the usual way to end the stories.
If you want the best recent volume, buy the Bloody Benders, a gory story with developments that pull you through multiple acts. With his next edition, Geary jumps to the 20th Century for the Lindbergh kidnapping. I'm looking forward to that, but I really hope he can continue to bring nineteenth century stories to the attention of fans and readers.
Murder is murder no matter what era... The Case of Madeleine Smith is one of the Treasury of Victorian Murder series. Rick Geary starts off with bibliographic references used in creating the book, a map of Scotland noting the towns germane to the major characters, and a map of the City of Glasgow in 1857 and its surrounding area. All these help the reader to visualize the relative locations of the action. The writing is clear and the artwork is amazing in that you can picture yourself in the story as an observer, and the surprise is when you look up and find yourself in your living room.
On Monday 23 March 1857, Emile L'Anglier arrives at his lodging house seriously ill. He dies later the same day. Notes in his journal cause the arrest of his fiancé Madeleine Smith, who is actually engaged to another man, William Minnock. But all the evidence points to Madeleine.
Geary clearly sets out the evidence going over the background of Emile L'Anglier and Madeleine Smith, the love affair, letters, journal entries, and actions prior to Emile's death. He covers the highlights of the court proceedings, the verdict, and follows up with what happened to some of the major characters in later years.
I found the writing clear and concise. Geary only sets forth the facts about what happened and lets the reader decide if the court's decision was the correct one. It would seem a cut and dried case but the prior history of the major figures casts doubts. What happened may not be what it seems -- there is definitely doubt about motives.
I think if more history was told as clearly with only the facts presented and the reader left to think about the ramifications and possible outcomes and how things might have been avoided or outcomes changed; it would make history much more exciting and interactive as a learning process. I found this illustrated presentation of The Case of Madeleine Smith thought provoking. The artwork is also clear and closely tied to the narrative so that the two are seamless as you're reading.
Sex and death in the not-so-Good Old Days Geary does what might be called documentary graphic novels, the best known of which is his series of true crime stories. This one is set in Glasgow in the late 1850s and involves an overly-romantic young gentleman and the young-ish daughter of a prominent architect who carry on a clandestine love affair -- until Madeleine gets tired of the whole thing, takes up with a man her father approves of, and then has to keep her paramour from outing her. Enter arsenic. The ex-boyfriend dies in great pain, the government brings murder charges, and a trial ensues. Even though their styles are nothing at all alike, Geary always reminds me of Edward Gorey -- the sly depiction of violence, the sense of inevitability, the decorous text. This is great stuff.
A good look at a mid-Victorian scandal This book is a graphic-novel overview of a murder case that gripped the attention of mid-nineteenth-century Britain: Did Madeleine Smith, Glasgow socialite, poison her inconvenient lover, Pierre L'Anglier, or didn't she?
Geary does not come down on the side of innocence or guilt; he presents the facts of the case, in his own inimitable drawing style, and lets the reader come to his or her own conclusions. I would say that the clue to innocence or guilt is there, but you have to be paying attention to see it---and I won't spoil the book for others by pointing it out. It's just one small fact that can't be explained otherwise.
This book's recommended for anybody interested in the case, or in true crime or classic crime in general. About the only reason I didn't give it five stars is that Geary apparently swallowed the story of Madeleine living her old age out in New York City out whole, without checking it out. It could be, but it also might not be, the truth---and without digging the corpse in question up and checking its DNA with known relatives of Smith, there's no way to know.
Anything Goes Trivia
Megaton Man
Tony's Online Tips
Trevor
