Product Description: Barbet Schroeder takes us down history's darkest paths in his attempt to illuminate the mystery behind an enigmatic figure, Jacques Vergès.
At the height of an illustrious career, Vergès disappeared without trace for eight years. When he returned, Vergès defended unpopular figures from all political fronts and monsters like Nazi criminal Klaus Barbie and Holocaust denier Roger Garaudy.
Amazon.com: In a free society, even the baddest of the bad are entitled to their day in court. Just ask French attorney Jacques Verges, the central figure in director Barbet Schroeder's Terror's Advocate and a fellow who has befriended and defended, with varying degrees of success, a lengthy list of terrorist bombers, serial killers, mass murderers, dictators, Nazis, and other villains. Born in 1925 in Thailand, the offspring of a French father and Vietnamese mother, he came to prominence in mid-1950s Algeria, when he agreed to represent accused bomber and anti-French militant Djamila Bouhired (after helping to get her death sentence repealed, Verges married her). Verges' style and tactics were established early on; viewed by his own government as a mercenary, traitor, and provocateur, he specialized in what he called the "rupture defense," in which he and his associates essentially refused to participate in the court proceedings. His clientele since then has included some of the most notorious scoundrels in 20th Century human history, among them Nazi war criminal Klaus "Butcher of Lyon" Barbie, the leftist revolutionary known as "Carlos the Jackal," Serbian dictator Slobodan Miloević, and an array of Palestinian hijackers and "freedom fighters," Islamic terrorists, African dictators, and so on. The Verges interviewed extensively in Schroeder's documentary is a smug, cigar-smoking, and utterly unapologetic man; as passionately as he may believe in the causes he's espoused, and there's little doubt of that, he's clearly quite comfortable with the notoriety, too. As for the documentary itself, what could have been fairly riveting at, say, 90 minutes is laborious, if edifying, at 137. Schroeder (whose previous credits include the likes of Reversal of Fortune and Barfly) uses considerable file footage to provide background and context for Verges' various cases, but with much of the running time occupied by static interviews with long-winded talking heads, Terror's Advocate too often makes your average PBS doc look like an episode of 24. --Sam Graham
Unfocused Study of Jacques Verges, Defender of Terrorists and Dictators. "Terror's Advocate" opens with the statement that the film presents director Barbet Schroeder's view of Jacques Vergès, but after 2 hours and 17 minutes documenting 5 decades of the controversial defense lawyer's career, I wish I knew what the director has to say about it. Jacques Verges is a Frenchman born in Thailand to a Vietnamese mother and a father from the Reunion Islands. Born under the yoke of French colonialism, or so he perceived, Verges became a communist and a proponent of all things anti-colonial, defending FLN bombers in Algeria and PFLP militants in Europe, before going on to cases altogether more mercenary, such as the defense of extortionist terrorist "Carlos" and "Butcher of Lyon" Klaus Barbie.
Verges, himself, is interviewed extensively for this film, sitting behind a desk in what looks like a luxurious home office, smugly puffing on a cigar. He doesn't make a convincing Marxist. He makes a better hedonist. But he tells us about his background, some of the cases he worked on, the people he met, always careful to cast his actions in the light of anti-colonialism and Western hypocrisy. Verges' associates are also interviewed, including many former terrorists, journalists, historians, and even an ex-Stasi agent. From these interviews, the film pieces together Verges' role in defending FLN bombers, including Djamila Bouhired, whom he later married, PFLP bombers, and his defense of Red Army Faction militants.
One problem with "Terror's Advocate" is that it spends most of its time explaining the "terrorist" or "revolutionary" organizations whose members Jacques Verges defended, leaving us to draw our own conclusions about his character with limited information. His career defending African autocrats is limited to a brief discussion of money that he was paid to defend Moise Tshombe and had to pay back. The film spends over half an hour on the FLN's battle in Algeria, a half hour on the 8 years he spent incognito, doing nothing, and 50 minutes on Carlos' organization in Europe in the 1970s and 1980s, whose connections to other revolutionary organizations seem as incoherent as its politics.
Jacques Verges is an intriguing subject, but he is an egotistical man who communicates by putting on a show, never revealing his real motivations. For this reason, a documentary about him needs to be deliberate in what it's saying, or it risks saying nothing. Verges' cases since 1978 have been more in service to his ego and his wallet than to his clients. Of course, he is such a fervent ideologue that even in his better days he couldn't see colonialism or its enemies realistically. And he long ago became a hypocrite. I doubt he cares. But Jacques Verges made a point of sticking his finger in the pie of every militant, leftist, or nationalist movement in Europe or Africa in the second half of the 20th century. He needs a more incisive biography than "Terror's Advocate". If you visit the film's web site, you will find that Barbet Schroeder does have a thoughtful opinion about Verges. It just doesn't come across in this film. In French, English, and German with English subtitles. The only bonus feature on the Magnolia 2008 DVD is a Historical Timeline of Verges' cases and events 1924-2005.
A surprisingly-good documentary Terror's Advocate is directed by Barbet Schroeder (Barfly), and features appearances from numerous individuals over the years, mostly in the form of archival footage. ***
Terror's Advocate is a documentary based on the life of Jacques Verges. Verges was a member of the Free French Forces, and later gained notoriety as a lawyer who defended some of the most detestable figures in history, from Klaus Barbie to Slobodan Milosevic. Through extensive usage of archive footage, the presentation paint's a clearer picture of this much-loathed man. ***
Terror's Advocate, despite its wildly controversial subject matter, is one of the most entertaining documentaries of last year. Director Barbet Schroeder puts all of the tools at his disposal to good use here - archival footage and research going back several decades, to name a few. It's tough to tell if Schroeder is trying to make us sympathize with Verges, or make us loathe him all the more with his not-so-pleasant resume of clients. Either way, I found this film to be one of the best documentaries to come along in a while. ***
The information in the film is all put together well, and beautifully paints a picture of Verges and the controversial life he has led. All of the research has been assembled well, and the archival footage only further helps to delve deeper into the mind of a man whose reputation is loathsome at best, with the clients he serves. Schroeder's film never feels biased, and above all, it sheds new light on an old subject. If you were to tell me that one of the best documentaries recorded in 2007 was one that revolve around a man who defended agents of terror, I certainly wouldn't have believed it. ***
I have only one issue with Terror's Advocate, and that's the overlong length. The film drags on for nearly two-and-a-half hours! I know there's a lot of information to pack into a relatively minimal amount of time (over half a century in just over two hours), but the thing does feel like overkill at times as a result. At least half an hour could have been trimmed, and it wouldn't have hurt the film any. Still, this doesn't change my positive review of the movie. ---
Image And Sound:
I viewed a screener disc, so the image quality doesn't represent the final product.
Special Features: None on the screener disc I reviewed.
Final Words:
If you're a fan of political documentaries, and you want one that explores a subject different from the war in Iraq or the American president who declared that war, Terror's Advocate is just the movie you need to see.
Anything Goes Trivia
Trevor
Megaton Man
