Good Intentions Are Not Sufficient This is a riveting movie concerning a family of Communists who unwittingly did incredible damage in South Africa during the early 1960s. It is based loosely on the real life experiences of Joe Slovo and Ruth First and their daughter, Shawn Slovo who wrote the script of "A World Apart." The system of apartheid was evil and most certainly had to be eradicated. Unfortunately, the doctrine of Marxist class warfare and near blind hatred of the oppressors will eventually cause more harm than good. The country is currently threatened with a major crime wave, severe economic troubles, and social disintegration. These people admittedly meant well, but much of their sacrificing was in vain. Aiding an unapologetic terrorist organization like the African National Congress is never worth it in the long run. The performances of Jodhi May and Barbara Hershey are astonishingly effective. Anyone who wants to better understand the tragedy of South Africa cannot ignore this movie.
A journey back in time This is truly a journey back in time to a sad period in the worlds history. It is a great coming of age story for Molly, the 13 year old daughter of anti aparheid activist parents.
aaaaaah ~ Humanity. HERSHEY is eviscerating as the victim of this quaint and still ever-present 'flick' of society.
Something to be watched and witnessed over and over again considering today's climate.
DVD?
Barbara Hershey is Diana Roth The most powerful movie about the monstruosity and the unhuman injustices of this white and racist regime in South Africa, called Apartheid. The action takes place in the 60's and the heroes are a couple of journalists risking their lives to fight it, writing burning articles. The husband is forced to leave the country and her wife, Diana Roth (wonderful Barbara Hershey) is arrested and convicted, with no trial or judgment.
The character spends most of the movie's running time between four walls or questioned by evil Akrikaner brutes. The fact that she's a white woman leads her only to psychological torture, not physical. She's finally definitely released after she tried to kill herself, refusing to give the names of the people she 'collaborated' with for her work. During her detention her young daughter Molly (played by Jodhi May), put away from the cause by her mother, discovers for over 90 days all the injustices and horrors all by herself (mother arrested and put into prison, black friend murdered, and her white friends turning away from her, accusing her for treason, including her best one, Yvonne) and tries to do something about it. The awakening is very brutal (in the beginning of the film, she sees a black man getting hit by a car and nobody to help him), and the drama is deep.
The force of this film, which was prized four times in Cannes Film Festival in 1988 (Special Jury Prize, Triple Best Actress Prize for Hershey, Johdi May and Linda Mvusi) is mostly in Hershey's performance. She carries all the film on her shoulders. The script, written by the journalist Shawn Slovo from her true story (based upon her childhood in South Africa and her relationship with her parents), is great, so is the direction of Chris Menges, here in his first 'fiction' film (after winning Oscars as director of photography, for Roland Joffé's films "The Killing Fields" and "The Mission"). The music, composed by Hans Zimmer ("Rain Man"), is the ideal one, moving and dramatic in the same time. This is another necessary film with no DVD release - so far -, good and powerful enough to be showed in all schools, and made to show how the most elementary rights of man can be shamefully and regularly wasted, and how those who try to respect these rights (white people included) are unceasingly hunted and, in most cases, finally get killed. We don't see films like this any more these days...
Sacrifices For Justice Barbara Hershey stars in this true life story of a white South African journalist who sacrifices her self and her family to try to bring an end to the injustices of Apartheid in 1960's South Africa. With her husband having fled the country, Hershey finds herself arrested under the Ninety Day Detention Act, leaving her 3 daughters in the care of her mother. It has a particularly hard effect on her sensitive oldest daughter, played by Jodhi May, who realizes more of what is going on to her family and country, and who also finds her self ostracized because of her parents' politics. The effect of South Africa's racial injustice is also seen on the family's maid, Linda Mvusi. The film gives viewers a solid look at the experience of Apartheid in 1960's South Africa, by showing the differences in the lifestyles of blacks and whites, and in the attitudes of the white characters towards blacks. It also raises the question of whether the Hershey character sacrificed her family too much in her pursuit of justice. Hershey is very good as the tough, crusading journalist, and May is excellent as her frustrated, confused, and awkward daughter. The cinematography and score are terrific, although the sound can be a problem in certain scenes where dialogue is difficult to hear. The violence is kept to a minimum so that this could be a great introduction for children into the history of South Africa. It's a small film well worth watching.
Anything Goes Trivia
Megaton Man
Tony's Online Tips
Trevor
