By: Homi K. Bhabha Publisher: Routledge Average Rating: Binding: Paperback Label: Routledge Number of Items: 1 Number of Pages: 333 Publication Date: June 14, 1990
Product Description: A classic collection of essays providing an excellent introduction to the many different narrations of the 'nation'. Contributors include Gillian Beer, Homi Bhabha, introduction to the many different narrations of the
What????? Boring, hard to read, hard to understand. Don't read it unless you have to or you're really interested in this topic.
Nation and Narration Great book! Very insightful concerning relationships with 'the other' (other cultures, other people, etc.).
Homi K. Bhabha How unfortunate that the previous reviewer had to resort to questioning a fellow reader's intellect and ability to read what is undoubtedly a complicately structured text. This type of comment epitimises the elitism that Bhabha is himself charged with. The inaccessability of this text to the wide majority of readers(and that is not due to a need for reading classes) has left Bhabha's 'liminal space' an area of discussion accessible only to a handful of individuals whose academic capital apparently surpasses that of their humility. There is no attempt made at any point in this book to explain what are undoubdtedly fascinating concepts in laymans terms, thereby excluding the vast majority of readers of all social strata for whom reading is a pleasure and not a struggle .
Enriching Experience I was mystified by the ignorance of a previous reviewer whose implications that Bhabha could not write clearly showed not only his stupidity, but perhaps also a marked LACK of reading classes. could i perhaps suggest to this gentleman that he take a reading class so that he is better equipped to deal with the prose, poetry and magic that abounds within this most important and significant of post-colonial discourses.
The polemic usefulness I don't like Homi Bhabha and I deeply dislike poscolonialist approaches. I think, as a passionate for literature that these theories have lead to forget the aesthetics of reading. I agree that Europe has crushed the periphery and all those ideas but I also don't believe that the solution is to create dangerous identities as totalizing as the European impositions. Nonetheless, I recognize that this book is very useful for anybody trying to understand the concept of nation. Bhabha articulates not very convincingly Fanon and Derrida, but the essays of Brennan and Sommer are excellent and the recovery of Renan's concept provides an excellent counterpoint. The book is a must for anybody interested in the topic, but still does not substite the reading of Said, Fanon and Benedict Anderson.
Anything Goes Trivia
Megaton Man
Tony's Online Tips
Trevor
