By: Alice Hoffman Publisher: Shaye Areheart Books Average Rating: Binding: Hardcover Label: Shaye Areheart Books Number of Items: 1 Number of Pages: 288 Publication Date: April 08, 2008 Release Date: April 08, 2008
Product Description: “Alice Hoffman is my favorite writer.” –Jodi Picoult
Alice Hoffman is one of our most beloved writers. Here on Earth was an Oprah Book Club selection. Practical Magic and Aquamarine were both bestselling books and Hollywood movies. Her novels have received mention as notable books of the year by the New York Times, Entertainment Weekly, the Los Angeles Times, and People magazine, and her short fiction and nonfiction have appeared in the New York Times, The Boston Globe Magazine, Kenyon Review, Redbook, Architectural Digest, Gourmet, and Self.
Now, in The Third Angel, Hoffman weaves a magical and stunningly original story that charts the lives of three women in love with the wrong men: Headstrong Madeleine Heller finds herself hopelessly attracted to her sister’s fiancé. Frieda Lewis, a doctor’s daughter and a runaway, becomes the muse of an ill-fated rock star. And beautiful Bryn Evans is set to marry an Englishman while secretly obsessed with her ex-husband. At the heart of the novel is Lucy Green, who blames herself for a tragic accident she witnessed at the age of twelve, and who spends four decades searching for the Third Angel–the angel on earth who will renew her faith.
Brilliantly evoking London’s King’s Road, Knightsbridge, and Kensington while moving effortlessly back in time, The Third Angel is a work of startling beauty about the unique, alchemical nature of love.
Ugh. For the longest time, I'd wanted to read one of Hoffman's books. I'm sorry I'd chosen this one.
And I'm also angry that I it took such effort to get through; the final 75 pages were actioned strictly by discipline alone.
I can't recall when I last read a novel that so was NOT what I had been led to believe, especially with all the accompanying blurbs, the acclaim, the press.
Pedestrian.
Wholly lacking energy.
A decided lack of literary merit.
At times I felt I was reading a bullet-point summary.
I have no idea if this novel is a good representation of Hoffman's talent. I do know that it is a good representation of bad storytelling, bad craft, bad execution.
In a nutshell, the premise of 'The Third Angel' was well beyond her skills. Indeed, her reach FAR exceeded her grasp. If you want to see how a masterful writer handles multiple story threads, weaving a magical fabric in a truly artistic way, try 'Fall On Your Knees' by Ann-Marie MacDonald. In fact, I'm thinking that doing that next is the only remedy to this awful taste in my mouth.
Imaginative but going nowhere Alice Hoffman has a gift of creative writing, but there is not much substance here in "The Third Angel". About 2/3 of the way through, I felt this book was just pulling me down, down, down and for no good reason-- and toward no particular end. No message to make the dreariness of these stories about unhappy people worth the time to read them, other than the fact that life is random in what it dishes out, and that lots of people make stupid choices. How depressing! This I can get by listening to the nightly news.
Also, most of the time I did not identify with the main characters in the 3 phases of the book. My own mother died of cancer while I was a young girl but nothing about the illness or death of a mother rang true for me. Perhaps this book feels more true for those who mourn the death of a spouse or child; other themes in the stories.
"The Third Angel" was a concept that was not very clearly impressed into my mind. I would have liked more development on that concept. It may have helped the book a lot.
This is a top ten book Let me explain how beautiful this book is. I read it, straight through, and burst into sobbing tears as I read the last two pages.
As I sat, in front of a hundred people, in a crowded airport gate in Philadelphia. And I didn't care, not one single bit.
I had a good cry, wiped my face, and immediately turned back to page one.
That's how beautiful this book is.
Paula in Tampa, FL
Absolutely Amazing "The doctor believed there were three angels," Alice Hoffman wrote in her 2008 novel The Third Angel, "The Angel of Life, who rode along with them most nights. The Angel of Death, who appeared wearing his funeral clothes on those visits when there was no hope. And then there was the Third Angel. The one who walked among us, who sometimes lay sick in bed, begging for human compassion." Hoffman's novel magically intertwines the stories of three women and their life's quests for faith, love, acceptance, and meaning.
We are first introduced to Maddy Heller, an American lawyer in London for her sister Allie's wedding to Paul in 1999. The themes of Maddy's life are misguided love, jealousy, and faith. Maddy is a very lonely, insecure woman who is desperately jealous of her sister. She never feels satisfied with her life. Maddy resents her father for leaving them when she was a child, her mother for loving her sister more than herself, and her sister for being "perfect." She falls in love with a man whom she knows does not love her back. She longs for him to call her, all the while professing that she has no faith in love or marriage. She has spent her life searching for something to believe in. A bundle of contradictions and raw emotion, Maddy is a realistic, complicated, and memorable character.
The second portion of the book deals with the story of Frieda Lewis, the mother of Paul. Frieda was present in the first chapter, but it is here that her character truly unfolds. Her story takes place in 1966 London. Frieda is the intelligent daughter of a country doctor who moves to London in search for something spectacular. She works at the Lion Park Hotel as a maid and falls for an up-and-coming rock star, Jamie. In the end, Frieda married another man because he was appropriate, and Jamie was killed in an accident. She wrote the songs that made Jamie famous, yet she is still alive and with her infant son because he rejected her. "[The Third Angel]'s the most curious," Hoffman writes, "You can't even tell if he's an angel or not. You think you're doing him a kindness, you think you're the one taking care of him, while all the while, he's the one who's saving your life."
The final portion ties the stories together flawlessly. It is the story of Lucy Green, the mother of Maddy and Allie Heller. The story takes place in 1952, when Lucy (a twelve-year-old) joins her father and step-mother in London to attend a wedding. She befriends a man named Michael Macklin at the Lion Park Hotel. He is the only adult who takes the time to talk to and understand the child. The reader will recognize his name from the two previous stories. In Lucy, we find the concepts of the need for acceptance and love, the desire to be heard, and uncontrollable grief for something you believe is your fault.
The themes of love and marriage run through all three story lines. But Hoffman does not romanticize them in the least. "There was good love, and there was bad love," she wrote. "There was the kind that helped raise a person above her failings and there was the desperate sort that struck when someone least expected it." Her concept of marriage is of a failed institution that does not necessarily work and certainly isn't "happily ever after."
Another important element in the novel is faith. All three main characters are searching for something to believe in.
The Third Angel is an excellent book with the power to break your heart and make you look into your own soul as it delves deeply into human nature and motivations. Alice Hoffman's novel is meticulously detailed and flows smoothly. Her characters are deep, believable, and so human. I enjoyed this book immensely. This was the first of Hoffman's novels that I have read, and from this experience I wouldn't hesitate to buy her books again.
by Jennifer Melville for Story Circle Book Reviews reviewing books by, for, and about women
Not my favorite, but I still love Alice Hoffman! I was so excited to read the latest book by Alice Hoffman that I actually bought the hardcover (I'm a paperback fan)and now wish I would have waited for the paperback version. I would have to say it was just, OK. I am a HUGE Hoffman fan and, to date, my all-time favorite book of her's is "The Ice Queen", where I fell in love with the characters immediately. In this latest book I found it a bit confusing and had to go back several times to make sure I had the characters all connected right and I found the story line to be a bit rushed. I did, as always, enjoy her style of writing but "The Third Angel" won't go up on my "must read" shelf and I won't be passing it on to friends, just re-selling it to a book store. Sorry, but I'm still a fan and am looking forward to her next book with fingers crossed that it will sweep me away as many of her books do!
Anything Goes Trivia
Megaton Man
Tony's Online Tips
Trevor
